Mass Merchant Fulfillment Performance Wavers Across Product Categories

specialty

Do shoppers have a better delivery experience ordering from ‘category-specific’ retailers than mass merchants? Think: L.L.Bean vs. Amazon for Apparel, HP vs. Costco for Electronics or Crate & Barrel vs. Sears for Home Furnishings.

We evaluated the fulfillment performance data of six mass merchants — Amazon, Costco, Kohl’s, Sears, Target, and Walmart — across three specific product categories: Apparel / Accessories, Electronics and Home Furnishings and compared performance to that of retailers specializing in that category.

The time frame for this study was May-July 2014, and the six mass merchants were:

  • Amazon
  • Costco
  • Kohl’s
  • Sears
  • Target
  • Walmart

The first three months of data tell an interesting story. Only two of the six outperformed the vertical across all three categories. That is, only two mass merchants — Costco and Sears — consistently delivered Electronics, Home Furnishings and Apparel faster on average than their category-specific …

Read More

Sears Rolls Out Curbside Returns, Exchanges

Sears-pickup

Sears has added returns and exchanges to its popular In-Vehicle Pickup service. The new integrated retail service, powered by the Shop Your Way mobile app, lets members pick up, return or exchange their purchases for free – guaranteed in five minutes or less – without ever leaving their vehicle.

It’s a great option for consumers, as Sears has struggled with refund speed in 2014. StellaService data shows the retailer’s Total Days to Refund has doubled since March, now averaging close to 14 days through August. Sears trails competitors like Amazon, Target and Walmart in the metric.

But, Sears has certainly found success in leveraging its physical stores to ship products faster. And, earlier this year the retailer aimed to better connect in-store and online shopping with the launch of In-Vehicle Pickup.

Curbside returns and exchanges takes that concept of convenience to the next level.

This is how it works:

  • To start an in-vehicle return or exchange, a customer visits sears.com, …

Read More

Survey Says Consumers Prefer Email During Holidays

Survey-says

Editor’s note: This article is excerpted from StellaService’s Q3 2014 report, Essential Holiday Ecommerce Data & Best Practices

StellaService polled consumers in August 2014 to understand expectations specific to the the holiday season. Topics ranged from customer care through shipping and returns.

The impact of delivering bad service impacts customer retention. Just 5% of shoppers said they would continue to shop with an online retailer after receiving bad service during the holidays.

Northeast U.S. shoppers are the most forgiving, with almost 10% reporting they would shop with a site that gave them bad service during the holidays. The South held a firm line with 71% of Southerners reporting they wouldn’t return to do business with an online retailer that gave them bad service.

More than half of respondents said that email is their preferred communication channel during the holidays, with phone coming in second at 28%.

Email is clearly the preference of holiday …

Read More

UPS to Hire Up to 95,000 Seasonal Workers

“UPS plans to hire up to 95,000 workers to help deliver packages during the busy holiday season — an increase from last year, when the company was caught unprepared for a boom in online shopping. The Atlanta-based company said Tuesday that the positions will include package sorters, loaders, delivery helpers and drivers.” [Source: ABC News]

Read More

Ecommerce Presents Challenges for UPS

“When United Parcel Service Inc. Chief Executive David Abney bought his first book from Amazon.com Inc. about 15 years ago, e-commerce seemed no more complicated than ordering from a catalog. “Pretty basic,” he says. Online sales have mushroomed since then into a huge business for the package-delivery company—and a big problem. Because of the ubiquity of free shipping, fierce competition from other delivery services and Amazon’s power to drive down shipping costs as it gets even more enormous, UPS’s average revenue on each Internet-related package it handles is dropping.” [Source: Wall Street Journal]

Read More